APA Male TV Anchors: Invisibility and Emasculation
Asian Pacific American male anchor? Not in a maritime sense, mate. But as in news anchor, the guy behind the desk, shuffling paper, smiling in front of the robotic camera, reading the prompter, shuffling news script like a prop and tossing it so affably from local tragedy to sports, traffic or weather.
The anchor is an American cultural icon. Walter Cronkite. Dan Rather. Tom Brokaw. Peter Jennings.
So wheres the Asian Pacific American guy?
Oh, yes. Lets not forget to mention James Hattori, formerly a weekend anchor at KRON and now host of CNNs tech show, and a few local exceptions in Los Angeles, guys who have ridden a TelePrompTer in their time. But as the major news anchor at their outlets? APA males just arent in that game.
If its about journalism, there are good, even great APA male reporters. Vic Lee, my former colleague at KRON, is a news monster. But you wont find him on the fast track to an anchor desk. There are sports and weather guys here or there. Raj Matthai is a great emerging sports star. But locally, and certainly not nationally, no APA male emerges on the same path as the one paved for Brian Williams, who stands waiting for Tom Brokaws last breath.
Why is that?
The question has been kicking around for years. Ever since Ken Kashiwahara was still the stud for ABCs now-defunct West Coast Bureau in San Francisco. Ever since I started as a young TV reporter in Reno. Ever since Connie Chung
thats another column.
But perhaps it explains why I was indifferent to the news that the Asian American Journalists Association was bringing up the issue yet again at their latest convention. I criticize the group often, mostly to spur them to action. But now I must commend them for dusting off this evergreen.
AAJA recently commissioned a study by USCs Annenberg School of Communications. Not only were our anecdotal fears confirmed, but the problem for APA guys is far worse than we thought.
In the top 25 local markets, there was just two APA male anchors. One in news, the other in sports.
Reporters? Just 18 guys, not quite one for every city.
If you were an APA guy, considering the low pay, would you say this was the field for you? In fact, a check of the journalism schools reflect very few APAs in the pipeline.
But heres the real problem: While males flounder, APA women are practically the chicken of the sea. Theyre out there in numbers.
Two APA male anchors in the top 25? There are 28 APA female anchors in the top 25.
In both reporting and anchoring, APA females outnumber APA males by nearly 5-1. Its not even close. You dont have to count the hanging chads.
And doesnt it feel like a spiked heel in the you-know-where?
Are you saying whats the big deal, Emil? Oh yeah, APA women are on the move, go sistahs! But then you miss the sinister aspect.
Theres some deeply-rooted race/gender matters at work here. And as its all played out on such a public stage as your living room, it matters a hell of a lot more than you think.
The anchor spot is not just about elevating the best journalist to the prime presenter spot. In television, we have moved from the news realm into the world of show business, the prime image generators in our culture. And if the media is the mirror, once again the message is clear for all: APA women rock, while APA men have no rocks.
Its the emasculation of the APA male and its happening daily at 5, 6 and 11. Or lets see it from the flip side: Its the selling of the APA female.
Is that more positive?
At the base of all this is, of course, sex appeal. Dont think that the attractiveness of APA females to white males isnt at play here. But USCs survey asked the mostly white male hiring managers about APA males. They saw them as smart, aggressive businessmen.
Great. APA guys are seen as threats.
But they also used the metaphorical phrase Asian Tiger, a phrase that more aptly describes the business face of Asian countries in the Pacific Rim. In other words, APA males are still seen as foreigners.
So its no surprise managers also mentioned Jackie Chan. Jackie Chan? The affable foreigner
who can kick your ass and entertain you.
Chan may be big box office, but thats because he plays the likeable happy-go-lucky karate guy. Hes the earnest buffoon. And hes sexless. In his next movie, The Tuxedo, do you think hes going to get Jennifer Love Hewitt? It minimizes his threat. Let him kick all he wants. He doesnt get the girl.
All these media images, or lack of them, snowball. And guess whom that impacts? More than ourselves, it impacts our sons.
When I raised this issue recently, I got a message from a father of a young APA. I worry for the future of my son who will not have the same social, political and economic opportunities of his white male counterparts growing up in this country, he told me.
More than invisibility, the lack of APA male anchors is just the most graphic example of our emasculation in America.
What I Really Think: A friend once told me in passing that I may have had an anchor shot if Id just had better hair. He was half-joking, but I realized he was probably right. In the 80s I still had Peter Frampton-hair. I was Roger Daltrey meets Jheri-curl Jackson. I was a slave to hair fashion. I didnt want to look like Walter Cronkite. But I didnt have to. I just had to look like me. And I owe my TV hair to my dear friend Alfons Skilandat, a gentlemans tonsorial artist, who practiced just a few blocks from San Franciscos Chinatown. More than a barber, Alfons was a master of going beyond the bowl haircut. He gave me my look. Alfons died last Saturday after a horrific 14-month battle with cancer. His son Ron, a master of hair couture carries on. But Ill never forget Alfons as the man who made me go straight.
Tipping allowed: Reach Emil Guillermo at emil@amok.com.
|